Discovering Vision Therapy Blog

Reading Specialist Discovers Why Her Child Was Struggling in School

Posted by The Vision Therapy Center

Homework was a nightmare.

There’s a reason why functional vision problems are called “the hidden disability.” It’s because so many parents, physicians and educators aren’t aware of them. In this case, a reading specialist discovered her daughter had a vision problem, and the subsequent treatment was an eye-opening experience.

As a second grader, Katie McGinley had always been a hard worker in school. But no matter how hard she tried, academically, things just weren’t clicking.

Katie McGinleyKatie McGinley

Parents know when their child is struggling, but Katie’s mother, Becky, was particularly attuned to the issue. Becky McGinley is a reading specialist in the Richfield School District.  Her job is to help children who are struggling in reading. She has encountered all types of reading issues in her experience, which was why her daughter’s struggles were particularly frustrating.

“Homework was a Nightmare.”

As the daughter of a reading specialist, Katie had always been surrounded by excellent instruction and great resources. But none of it seemed to matter. “Homework was a nightmare,” Becky recalled.  “It would take forever.” 

Homework was taking forever.

Katie would struggle with writing, and she complained that her book was always moving around.

Her struggles at home were also reflected in her test scores.  With her reading scores, she always made it to the benchmarks, but always at the low end.  Katie’s progress frustrated her mother, who was trying everything she could to help her daughter.

“We were doing so much work at home,” she said.  “She should have been making more progress.”

A Surprising Discovery

With co-workers and medical practitioners stumped, Becky decided to explore other options.

A friend mentioned the possibility of having Katie tested at The Vision Therapy Center.

Becky took Katie and her brother and sister (they’re triplets!) to be evaluated.  After a Functional Vision Test, she was surprised to discover her daughter suffered from convergence excess.

The Functional Vision Test showed the problem.

Convergence excess is essentially the opposite of convergence insufficiency. Instead of the eyes being unable to efficiently converge on a single point, the person over-converges. It results in impairment of functional vision similar to convergence insufficiency.

Becky had never heard of the condition, nor that it could impact reading by causing eyestrain, headaches, fatigue, distractibility and inconsistent concentration. She also was unaware of the recommended treatment: Vision therapy.

Making the Commitment

Katie’s convergence excess was affecting her functional vision.  But what is functional vision?  

Functional vision is how your entire visual system -- the eyes, the brain, the visual pathways -- work together to help you interact with your environment. It includes the visual skill areas of eye teaming, eye focusing and eye movement.  

Through a series of activities and exercises, vision therapy can help improve functional vision skills -- and in this case, improved Katie’s eye teaming skills to overcome her convergence excess.

Starting vision therapy was an easy choice.

Despite the fact that Becky was unfamiliar with vision therapy, and that the McGinley family’s insurance didn’t cover the treatment, moving forward was an easy choice.  “It was a financial commitment, but I can’t teach the vision corrections,” Becky said.

Running the Marathon and Winning the Race

Vision therapy treatment can range in length, but most treatments run six to nine months.  Katie’s treatment program took seven months.  This involved a combination of vision therapy performed once a day at home for five/six days a week, and then one office visit per week at The Vision Therapy Center.

Becky said they described the treatment to Katie as “running a marathon, not a quick sprint.”  The commitment was huge -- 25 minutes every night, on top of homework, sports and activities.

Charts helped show progress.

“We made a goal chart and a calendar to keep her going,” Becky recalled.  “We also shared with her how it was working.”

Making Progress -- Inside the Classroom and Out

After the first two months, Becky noticed improvement in a rather unexpected place: Becky’s behavior.  “She became very confident, and she was able to concentrate and focus on her homework,” she said.

After seven months, Katie made huge gains at increasing her reading level.  Where she was at the low-end of the benchmark, she’s now in the mid-range. She can also read comfortably at home or in the car. “She’ll put her glasses on and settle into the zone,” Becky said.

"I was fierce!"

Her confidence has soared beyond the classroom. On the soccer field, she used to be nervous and unsure of herself. Now she plays with confidence and intensity.  “She came off the field one day and said, ‘Mom, I was fierce! They couldn’t get the ball past me!’” Becky recalled.

Helping to Spread the Word Among Other Reading Specialists

Graduation from vision therapy for Katie was an extremely proud moment for all involved.  She had worked hard over a long period of time, and achieved her goal.  It was a huge sense of accomplishment for Katie.

Katie with Vision Therapist Natali Sutermeister.Katie with Vision Therapist Natali Sutermeister.

It also made Becky aware of how many functional vision problems were occurring in her own classroom.  She’s been sharing Katie’s story with her administration and fellow teachers, and the reactions have been positive.  

Hear Becky's message to fellow educators in this interview: 


With the full support of her administration, Becky is recommending that parents at least consider having a Functional Vision Test conducted if their child appears to be struggling because of a vision problem.

Awareness was what finally led to Katie’s eventual treatment. Join us in helping make other people aware of functional vision problems -- please share this story on social media. And if you believe your child may have an issue, take The Vision Quiz to learn more about the symptoms of a vision problem.

Take The Vision Quiz Now

Topics: Success Stories, Reading Problems